Skip to content
The RecordVol. I
Hall of ShameA catalog of baseball's lasting mistakes

About the record

A museum, not a roast.

The Hall of Shame is a catalog of 67 classic major-league blunders: the missed base, the uncovered plate, the trade that only looks obvious afterward, the promotion that ended in a forfeit. The tone is editorial. The standard is the box score.

An entry starts with what happened, then with what the retelling added. Fred Snodgrass dropped a fly and, in the same inning, made a difficult catch. Bill Buckner's error came after the Red Sox had already lost the lead. Don Denkinger missed a call, and the Cardinals then missed a popup, a pitch, and the next day. Where a nickname outruns the evidence — the "$30,000 muff," the 1908 version of Germany Schaefer stealing first, a soaked glove in a Chicago dugout — the entry says so.

Some famous shame is not in this volume on purpose. Ray Chapman's death is a tragedy, not a blooper. Donnie Moore's 1986 pitch is bound up with a suicide, and reducing a life to one slider would be a second cruelty. On-field assaults are left out. The Black Sox scandal was a crime. Those subjects deserve a different room.

The catalog is a local JSON file, with stable ids on every entry, player, and team, so it can move later to a database without renaming the public record. A player page or a team page gathers the entries that already name that id. A suggestion, a correction, or a public-domain image can be offered on the suggestion page. The form is a placeholder and does not send anything yet.

Eras

The era filter follows the game's own chapters, not round decades. A sale announced in January 1920 belongs to the live-ball years.

  • Dead Ball Era1900–1919 · 6Low scoring, aggressive baserunning, and the first modern scapegoats.
  • Live Ball Era1920–1945 · 7The lively ball, the Yankees' rise, and World Series played in daylight.
  • Postwar Era1946–1960 · 4Integration, television, and a pennant that turned on one pitch.
  • Expansion Era1961–1976 · 9New franchises, the amateur draft, and promotions that got away.
  • Free Agency Era1977–1993 · 20October became a television event, and so did the mistakes.
  • Wild Card Era1994–2011 · 16More playoff games, more cameras, and less room to hide a misplay.
  • Modern Era2012–present · 5Replay, challenges, and the calls that still belong to a human being.

Categories

Sources

Play-by-play comes first from Retrosheet and Baseball-Reference. Narrative corrections come from the Society for American Baseball Research, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, and reporting in the daily papers of the day. Photographs in this volume are public-domain images, credited on the entry, or the entry stands without one. Film slots exist in the data model and stay empty until a clip can be embedded without pretending a rights-holder's broadcast is free.