Skip to content
The RecordVol. I
Hall of ShameA catalog of baseball's lasting mistakes

Team

New York Mets

8 entries · 1962–2023

No. 1962.06.17

1962

June 17
Baserunning Blunders1962

Throneberry Misses the Base

Marv Throneberry hit what looked like a two-run triple and was called out for missing first. He later admitted he had missed second, too.

New York Mets · Chicago Cubs

No. 1969.09.09

1969

September 9
Fan & Crowd Moments1969

A Black Cat at Shea

A black cat walked in front of the Cubs' dugout at Shea. Chicago lost, 7–1. The standings, not the cat, are what the collapse was.

Chicago Cubs · New York Mets

No. 1971.12.10

1971

December 10
Front Office & Trades1971

Nolan Ryan for Jim Fregosi

The Mets traded Nolan Ryan and three others to the Angels for Jim Fregosi. Ryan left with seven no-hitters. Fregosi was gone in a season and a half.

New York Mets · California Angels

No. 1977.06.15

1977

June 15
Front Office & Trades1977

Seaver to Cincinnati

On the night of the trading deadline, the Mets sent Tom Seaver to Cincinnati for four players, and Dave Kingman to San Diego in a separate deal.

New York Mets · Cincinnati Reds · San Diego Padres

Bill Buckner in a Red Sox uniform, about 1986. This is not a photograph of the tenth inning.
Fielding Fiascos1986

The Ball Gets Through Buckner

The Red Sox were one out from a title when a ground ball went through Bill Buckner's legs. By then the lead was already gone.

Boston Red Sox · New York Mets

Luis Castillo with the Mets on June 23, 2008. This is not the popup at Yankee Stadium on June 12, 2009.
Fielding Fiascos2009

Castillo Drops the Popup

The Mets led by a run with two outs in the ninth when Luis Castillo dropped Alex Rodriguez's popup, then threw to the wrong base.

New York Mets · New York Yankees

Matt Harvey being interviewed, June 9, 2015 (the same season). Not World Series Game 5.
Managerial Decisions2015

Harvey Talks His Way Back

Terry Collins let Matt Harvey pitch the ninth of World Series Game 5 with a two-run lead. Harvey walked a man and gave up a double. Eric Hosmer then scored the tying run on a throw Lucas Duda did not get to the plate.

Kansas City Royals · New York Mets

Max Scherzer with the Mets, April 7, 2023, 12 days before the ejection. Not the moment.
Rules & Quirks2023

Scherzer's Hand

In the fourth inning at Dodger Stadium, the umpires checked Max Scherzer's hand and glove, ruled them too sticky, and threw him out. Major League Baseball suspended him ten games. He said it was rosin and sweat.

New York Mets · Los Angeles Dodgers