Skip to content
The RecordVol. I
Hall of ShameA catalog of baseball's lasting mistakes

Team

St. Louis Cardinals

11 entries · 1926–2020

No. 1926.10.10

1926

October 10
Baserunning Blunders1926

Ruth Is Out at Second

The 1926 World Series ended with Babe Ruth thrown out at second. He said he was stealing on his own. Other accounts say a hit-and-run was on.

New York Yankees · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 1934.10.09

1934

October 9
Fan & Crowd Moments1934

Medwick and the Fruit Barrage

After a hard slide in Game 7, Detroit fans threw fruit, bottles, and vegetables at Joe Medwick until the commissioner took him out of the game.

St. Louis Cardinals · Detroit Tigers

No. 1946.10.15

1946

October 15
Baserunning Blunders1946

Slaughter Scores from First

Enos Slaughter scored from first on Harry Walker's double in Game 7. The relay went through Johnny Pesky, who said he hesitated. Later viewings say the run was coming anyway.

St. Louis Cardinals · Boston Red Sox

No. 1964.06.15

1964

June 15
Front Office & Trades1964

Brock for Broglio

The Cubs traded Lou Brock to the Cardinals for Ernie Broglio in a six-player deal. Brock finished with 3,023 hits. Broglio won seven games in Chicago.

Chicago Cubs · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 1964.09.21

1964

September 21
Managerial Decisions1964

The Phillies' 1964 Collapse

Philadelphia led the league by 6½ games with twelve to play. Gene Mauch kept running his aces out on short rest. The Phillies lost ten in a row.

Philadelphia Phillies · Cincinnati Reds · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 1985.10.16

1985

October 16
Managerial Decisions1985

Lasorda Pitches to Clark

With first base open in the ninth of the 1985 NLCS, Tommy Lasorda let Tom Niedenfuer pitch to Jack Clark. Clark hit the first pitch into the left-field seats.

Los Angeles Dodgers · St. Louis Cardinals

Jorge Orta, from his 1978 Hostess baseball card. This is not the 1985 call at first base.
Umpire Controversies1985

Denkinger Calls Orta Safe

With St. Louis one out from a championship, Don Denkinger called Jorge Orta safe at first. Replays showed he was out. The Cardinals never got the inning back.

Kansas City Royals · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 2000.10.03

2000

October 3
Pitching Disasters2000

Rick Ankiel Loses the Plate

Rick Ankiel was twenty-one, a phenom, and ahead 6–0 in his first playoff start. In the third inning he threw five wild pitches and could not find the strike zone.

St. Louis Cardinals · Atlanta Braves

No. 2011.10.27

2011

October 27
Fielding Fiascos2011

The Ball over Cruz

With two outs in the ninth of World Series Game 6, David Freese's ball went over Nelson Cruz's head and tied the game. Texas led again in the tenth. St. Louis won in the eleventh.

Texas Rangers · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 2012.10.05

2012

October 5
Umpire Controversies2012

The Infield Fly in Atlanta

With the Braves rallying in a winner-take-all game, Sam Holbrook called the infield fly rule on a ball that fell in short left field. The crowd threw trash for nineteen minutes.

Atlanta Braves · St. Louis Cardinals

No. 2020.01.09

2020

January 9
Front Office & Trades2020

Arozarena to Tampa

St. Louis traded Randy Arozarena and José Martínez for Matthew Liberatore and other pieces. That October Arozarena hit ten home runs in the postseason, a record, on the way to the World Series.

St. Louis Cardinals · Tampa Bay Rays